In the pantheon of Abbott Elementary ’s flawless first season, Episode 9—“Step by Step”—stands as the moment the show fully commits to its most chaotic force: Principal Ava Coleman. While earlier episodes used Ava as a punchline (the TikTok-obsessed, embezzling administrator who’d rather nap than lead), this episode transforms her into a genuine antagonist, then shockingly, into something almost vulnerable. It’s a 22-minute masterclass in cringe comedy, workplace ethics, and the surprising power of a well-timed documentary crew.
The episode opens with Ava announcing a school-wide “film festival” meant to boost morale. Her contribution? A deeply inappropriate, self-directed “movie” starring herself, filmed entirely on school grounds, featuring suggestive dialogue, dramatic slow-motion walks down the hallway, and—inexplicably—a cameo from a stolen janitor’s cart. The other teachers are horrified. Janine, ever the optimist, tries to see the artistic value. Gregory, ever the pragmatist, stares into the camera like he’s on The Office and Jim just told him Michael ate a whole tiramisu.
One of the strongest outings of Season 1, essential viewing for anyone who’s ever worked under a bizarre boss, and proof that Abbott isn’t just a funny school sitcom—it’s a sharp, empathetic look at how we show up for each other, even when we’re showing up badly. abbott elementary s01e09 aiff
And here’s where the episode transcends typical sitcom fare. During her apology, Ava, for the first time, drops the mask. She admits she doesn’t know how to be a principal, that she took the job because it paid better than her previous “hustles,” and that she genuinely thought making people laugh was enough. It’s a raw, three-line confession delivered with a shrug, and it recontextualizes every lazy moment before it. The documentary crew captures Janine’s face softening, Gregory’s jaw unclenching, and the audience realizing: Oh, this show has depth.
Best line: “I call it Ava: License to Chill . The board called it ‘a liability.’ Same thing, really.” – Ava Coleman In the pantheon of Abbott Elementary ’s flawless
While Ava dominates, the rest of the cast gets stellar moments. Janine’s attempt to “help” Ava edit her film—suggesting title cards and a “learning objective”—is peak Quinta Brunson earnestness. Gregory’s deadpan critique (“You can’t solve budget cuts with a dance break, Ms. Coleman”) lands perfectly. And the final scene, where the teachers reluctantly agree to screen a different student film (a sweet, boring documentary about pencils), ends with Ava whispering to Janine, “Next year, I’m adding explosions.” It’s a promise and a threat.
Janelle James deserves an Emmy for this episode alone. Ava’s film is so spectacularly tone-deaf—she plays a “secret agent teacher” who solves problems by “using her feminine wiles on the school board”—that you can’t look away. But the genius of “Step by Step” is that it doesn’t let Ava off the hook. When the district catches wind of the video (thanks to a parent who “accidentally” saw it while helping with homework), Ava faces actual consequences: a formal review, possible termination, and—worst of all—being forced to apologize. The episode opens with Ava announcing a school-wide
The B-plot follows Jacob attempting to help his students produce a historically accurate documentary about the school’s founding, only to realize that Abbott Elementary’s history is mostly “a series of broken boilers and one raccoon infestation.” Meanwhile, Melissa and Barbara—the veteran Greek chorus—exchange weary glances that say more than any script could. Their silent judgment of Ava’s antics is comedy gold, especially when Barbara mutters, “She’s going to get us all on a list.”